Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara has long dominated the conversation in the beauty sphere, often holding the title of the best mascara more by reputation than by constant innovation. While the original formula remains a cult favorite, the brand has since expanded the line to include variants like the Better Than Sex Waterproof and the Tubing versions, each promising enhanced volume and length. This review dissects the performance of these formulas to determine if the hype still holds true for modern lash expectations.
Formulation and Initial Application
Stepping away from the generic comparisons, the texture of the classic Better Than Sex is undeniably creamy and buttery upon application. This dense consistency allows the brush to deposit a significant amount of product with minimal effort, which is the primary driver behind its immediate volumizing effect. The wax-based formula grips each lash, building thickness that feels substantial rather than stiff, creating a look that is often described as false but in a natural way.
The Anatomy of the Brush
The Curved Wand Design
The signature hourglass-shaped brush is the defining feature of this mascara and the reason for its initial success. The dense bristles curve to fit the natural shape of the eye, effectively coating lashes from root to tip without skipping. This design excels at separating lashes during the swiping motion, preventing clumps that can occur with straight, plastic rods, thereby creating the illusion of fullness that defines the "better than sex" experience.
Performance Wear and Endurance
Performance is where this mascara truly lives or dies, and it is a study in duality. The film-forming polymer ensures that the volume holds strong against humidity and the natural oils of the eyelids. However, this strength becomes a liability when it comes to removal; the waterproof version requires an oil-based cleanser to dissolve the waxy buildup thoroughly. Users with sensitive eyes may find the formula slightly drying, necessitating the use of a gentle eye makeup remover to avoid irritation.
Exceptional volume and length in a single coat.
The curved brush provides excellent root-to-tip coverage.
Minimal clumping compared to other volumizing formulas.
Waterproof variants offer superior resistance to smudging.
Removal can be aggressive, potentially stressing lashes over time.
The formula can sometimes feel too heavy for those with fine lashes.
Modern Alternatives and Comparisons
In the current market, the definition of "better" has shifted toward lightweight, fiber-based, and tubing formulas that prioritize lash health. While the Too Faced version remains a benchmark for drama, newer competitors offer similar lift with less weight. The tubing variants, in particular, create a waterproof tube around each lash that can be dissolved easily with water, offering a less intense removal process that is kinder to natural lashes.
Ideal Use Cases and Limitations
This mascara is not a subtle enhancement; it is a transformative product designed for evening wear or special events where maximum impact is desired. It performs exceptionally well on straight or upward-growing lashes, creating a wide-eyed, doll-like effect. However, those with very short or sparse lower lashes may find the formula too dramatic, as the wand can transfer easily during application, resulting in smudges under the eye.
Verdict on Longevity
When evaluating the "too faced better than sex mascara review" narrative, longevity is the strongest point. A single coat can maintain its volume for approximately eight hours without significant smudging or raccoon eyes. The formula resists flaking and maintains its consistency throughout the day, although it may accumulate some residue at the base of the lashes, which is a common trade-off for such intense pigmentation.
